You’ve made a deal and are about to take the keys to your new car. There’s only one major thing left to decide: how you’ll pay for it. Dealer financing vs credit union? This’s a common conundrum for many new car shoppers, and your decision can affect your total cost of ownership by hundreds or even thousands of dollars over the life of the loan.
Island Federal has helped Long Island car buyers tackle this decision since 1955, and we’ll help you too. Read on to learn more about whether dealer financing or credit union auto loans are best for your situation.
How Dealer Financing Works
As the name implies, dealer financing is when a car buyer finances through the dealership they’re buying from and the network of third-party lenders or captive finance companies that they work with. The biggest advantage of dealer auto financing is the convenience of arranging your car loan where you’re buying the vehicle. However, you should know a few other things about dealer financing.
Dealer Rate Markups and How Dealers Get Paid
Dealers offer financing because they can make money off this service. Typically, dealers work with a preferred lender at a base interest rate, or buy rate, and then mark it up when they approve the loan to buyers to ensure they profit from financing. In some cases, buyers spend time and energy negotiating the vehicle’s price and don’t bother to negotiate financing details, which can cause them to lose track of the true cost of their purchase.
Manufacturer Promotions and 0% APR Offers
Many dealers advertise financing offers, such as 0% APR or manufacturer promotions. While these can attract car buyers and help them save money, they often come with a few caveats. One, many financing deals are only available for brand-new models and buyers with excellent credit, so not everyone will qualify for credit approval. Second, these promotions may require buyers to forgo cash-back rebates or other incentives.
The bottom line is that 0% APR and other financing incentives aren’t always cheaper than taking the cash rebates and taking out a standard low-interest bank loan. Run the math so you can make the best decision.
Buy Here, Pay Here Lots
Some in-house car dealership financing is designed to help buyers with poor or limited credit. Loans for these types of buyers often come with high interest rates, larger down payments and a greater risk of repossession if terms of the loan aren’t met. Credit unions, conversely, are more willing to work with borrowers who have limited or poor credit and offer loans that fit their financial situation.
How Credit Union Auto Loans Work
Credit unions are non-profit, member-owned financial institutions that return value to their members through better rates and lower fees. Membership is required, but they’re easy to join. Some benefits of working with a credit union for your next auto loan include:
Local Lending and Personalized Service
Credit unions are embedded in the community where you live and work, making your local credit union more likely to provide personalized and local service. They’ll also look beyond just your three-digit FICO score and examine the full financial picture to find the best solution for your situation. This level of service reflects credit unions’ member-focused values. They don’t report profits to investors or stakeholders; they work for you.
Getting Pre-Approved Before You Shop
The biggest benefit of working with a credit union on your next auto loan is that you can get pre-approved before you start shopping for a new or used vehicle. This allows you to set a clear budget and know exactly what you can and cannot afford. It can also give you more negotiating power. At Island Federal, pre-approval is no-cost and there’s no commitment to work with us if you find a better auto loan opportunity elsewhere.
Credit Union Auto Loan Rates vs Dealer Financing: Side-by-Side Comparison
Curious about credit union auto loan rates vs dealer financing? In most cases, you can secure a better interest rate through a credit union, but you should also consider other factors when choosing an auto loan. Here’s a look:
Credit Union | Dealer Financing | |
Interest Rate | As low as 4.99% at Island Federal | Varies; national average is 6.35% for new vehicles and 11.19% for used vehicles |
Rate Markups | None | 1-2.5% above lender’s approved base rate |
Loan Terms | Flexible terms, anywhere from 12-96 months | Standard terms tied to lender or captive finance rules |
Pre-approval | Yes, gives buyers more leverage | Is completed on site after buyer selects vehicle |
Transparency | High | Varies; dealers often focus on monthly payment versus total cost |
Pressure | Low | High |
What the Difference Looks Like Over the Life of a Loan
Consider more than your monthly payment; focus on the total cost of vehicle ownership. For example, here’s a look at the total cost of the vehicle loan when considering a 72-month loan at a 4.99% interest rate and a 6.35% interest rate, assuming the vehicle price is $40,000 and you put zero down:
- 4.99%: Monthly payment is $644, and total interest paid is $6,368.85. The total cost of the vehicle is $46,368.85.
- 6.35%: Your monthly payment is $669.54, and the total interest paid is $8,207.18. The total cost of the vehicle is $48,207.18.
Use this calculator to do your own math and see the vehicle’s total cost.
Pros and Cons of Dealer Financing
Thinking that dealer financing is your best path? Here’s a look at pros and cons to consider as you weigh your decision:
Pros:
- Convenience of buying and financing the vehicle under one roof.
- You can likely get same-day loan approval.
- You’ll likely qualify for manufacturer promotions.
Cons:
- You may be subject to interest rate markups.
- The dealer may pressure you into bundling add-ons, which can increase the vehicle’s total cost.
- The process is less transparent, and dealers may pressure you to sign on the spot.
Pros and Cons of Credit Union Auto Loans
Here’s a look at the pros and cons of working with a credit union on your next auto loan:
Pros:
- You likely qualify for lower interest rates.
- You can receive pre-approval before car shopping, which can give you more negotiating power.
- Terms are transparent and member-focused (i.e., no early payoff penalties, etc.)
Cons:
- You must be a credit union member to qualify for an auto loan (or any offered products).
- You have to work with the credit union and the dealer, which requires an extra step in the process.
When Dealer Financing Might Make Sense
In any situation, stay informed and choose the financing option that works best for you. For example, if you have excellent credit and qualify for 0% APR promotions, that would outweigh any cash-back rebates; working with the dealer is likely to be the better option. In any case, it’s still a good idea to bring a credit union pre-approval to the dealer so you can compare offers from banks and credit unions side by side.
Dealer Financing Red Flags to Watch For
Due to the tendency of dealers to be more high-pressure and less transparent, it’s important to be on the lookout for these red flags:
- Negotiating only over monthly payment, while glossing over loan terms and other details.
- Trying to stretch loan terms to decrease your monthly payment.
- Extended warranties, GAP coverage or other add-ons they try to roll into the loan without any clear explanation.
Some dealerships may also practice unethical “Yo-Yo” financing. Also known as “spot delivery,” this occurs when you drive off with a new car before the loan is officially approved. Days or weeks later, you’ll be notified that the loan wasn’t approved and asked to return to the dealer to sign a new auto loan, often at a higher interest rate.
How to Use a Credit Union Pre-Approval at the Dealership
Even if you’re interested in financing through a dealership, credit union pre-approval is a helpful tool. To receive credit union pre-approval, follow these steps:
- Join a credit union if you’re not already a member.
- Apply for pre-approval.
- Shop and negotiate the vehicle price based on your approval.
- Negotiate the vehicle price before you talk about financing.
- Once you agree on a price, you can finance through the dealer or your credit union.
Already Financed Through the Dealer? Refinance It
Did you already finance through your dealer? Don’t be afraid to look into refinancing options to see if you can save money over the loan term. Refinancing with a credit union can often secure a lower interest rate, which can decrease your monthly payment or help you pay off your loan faster. At Island Federal, we offer the same low advertised rate on most refinances as we do on new loans.
Why Long Island Drivers Choose Island Federal for Auto Loans
Car buyers throughout Long Island have long sought Island Federal for auto loans thanks to our low rates on new, used and refinanced vehicles, flexible loan terms and other value-added benefits. We also offer a First Time Car Buyer program and a car-buying portal to make your next vehicle search fast and convenient.
Walk Into the Dealership With Your Rate Already Locked In
In the market for a new vehicle and looking to get the most value for your money? Contact Island Federal today to see how we can help you secure a low rate and empower you with stronger negotiating power than you’d get from typical dealer financing. Contact us today or stop into one of our Long Island branches for loan pre-approval and to start your new car-buying journey.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it better to finance a car through a credit union or a dealership?
It’s typically best to finance through a credit union to take advantage of lower rates and better terms.
Are credit union auto loan rates lower than dealer financing rates?
Yes, credit union auto loan rates are usually 1-2% lower than dealer financing rates.
Can I use a credit union loan to buy a car from any dealership?
Yes, you can use credit union auto loans to buy a car from any dealership.
Can a dealer beat a credit union auto loan rate?
Yes, dealerships can beat credit union auto loan rates, but usually only when offering promotions or other incentives.
Does getting pre-approved for an auto loan hurt my credit score?
Pre-approval is a hard inquiry, which usually causes a small, temporary drop in your credit score.
Should I take a 0% APR dealer offer or a cash rebate with credit union financing?
Take the option with the lower total cost of ownership. Run the math on the price, rebates and credit union interest rate, and select the option with the lowest total cost.
Can I refinance a dealer auto loan with a credit union?
Yes, this is often done to secure a lower interest rate or better terms.
Do I need to be a member of Island Federal to get an auto loan?
Yes, you must be a member of Island Federal to access our financial products and offerings.